All posts

The Arabs Who Can Beat Bibi

Lior Mizrahi / Getty Images

Israel’s second election of the year has demonstrated more clearly than ever that the most important oppositional actor in the country is its Palestinian minority.

Note from LeftEast editors: We re-post this article from Jacobin, where it was published on 22.09.2019

Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has made it a habit, at times of political exigency, to incite vocally and explicitly against “The Arabs,” the 20% of Israel’s population composed of indigenous Palestinians. On election day of 2015, he famously whipped up support among his base by announcing on social media that “the Arabs are flocking to the polls in buses,” as if their participation were a danger to democracy rather than its consummation. In the run-up to the inconclusive election held this spring, Netanyahu accused his rival Benny Gantz of plotting to include “the Arab parties” in a coalition. This accusation was quickly denied by Gantz, who has made sure to leave no political daylight between himself and Netanyahu’s Likud party, focusing his campaign solely on the latter’s personal corruption. True to form, a few days before the election day this Thursday, Likud managed to get a court injunction against a civil-society effort to get out the vote among the severely disadvantaged Bedouin Palestinians in Israel’s south, and Bibi again spent election day warning darkly (and illegally) of the danger of high Arab turnout.

This time, however, the gambit seems to have backfired. Netanyahu’s base, perhaps tired of his desperate clinging to power despite a growing number of corruption investigations, stayed home in large numbers, handing a plurality to Gantz’s party, Blue-White, which has won 33 seats to Likud’s 31 (out of 120). This plurality does not guarantee Gantz the premiership; since neither his “center-left” block (including Labor and Meretz) nor Netanyahu’s “right-religious” block (including the far-right Yemina and the ultra-orthodox Shas and Torah Judaism) have a majority, the country is in for a long round of horse-trading which might only be resolved with yet another election.

But Netanyahu’s racist incitement has also backfired in a way which may have more profound long-term implications for Israeli politics. The four Palestinian-majority parties which united in 2015 to form the Joint List – a national front of leftists, Islamists, liberals and local leaders – fell apart before the previous election after two years of embarassingly non-ideological bickering and were duly punished by the voters, losing three seats. The rematch gave the parties an opportunity to get their act together, and upon its reunification the Joint List was able to match its earlier achievement and reach 13 seats, making it the third-largest force in the Knesset.
Ayman Odeh, the head of the Joint List, may or may not officially be the next Leader of the Opposition, depending on how coalition talks work out. In practice, however, he has already taken on the role. In part this is a technical victory, the result of the utter collapse of the parties of the Zionist left, Labor and Meretz, which have plummetted from a combined 36 seats twenty years ago to a mere 12 in the last two elections. Beginning with the Second Intifada or Palestinian uprising of 2000-04, the mostly Ashkenazi (European-origin) and secular middle class abandoned these parties in droves for a succession of militaristic, neoliberal and anti-religious center parties of which Blue-White is only the latest.

However, the Joint List under Odeh has also slowly become the face of a newly united and active political force: the Palestinian citizens of Israel. The “Arabs of ‘48” is a trapped minority facing discrimination, marginalization and poverty, but is also sometimes stigmatized in the Palestinian and Arab world as a collective of collaborators or spoiled “cream Arabs.” Some political forces within the minority, among them both leftists and Islamists, see Israel as an illegitimate state and traditionally boycott the elections. Others, including the mayor of Israel’s largest Palestinian city, Nazareth, see the mainstream leadership as too concerned with the occupation and would like the community’s leaders to concentrate on internal issues. Between these two poles, Odeh has managed to chart a course which maintains the Joint List’s commitment to the Palestinian people in general and to ending the occupation in particular, while also demanding the minority’s share of the cake of political and economic power within Israel – including a willingness, in principle, to enter negotiations on joining a coalition government.

For the time being, such an eventuality remains entirely hypothetical, as Blue-White is unwilling to entertain the demands of the Joint List, which include the repeal of the recent “Nation-State Law” which codifies the discrimination Palestinian citizens suffer and immediate negotiations for an end to the occupation based on the relevant UN resolutions. But the shrunken parties of the Zionist left, who have long ignored the “Arab parties,” have finally begun to treat Odeh as befits the leader of a far larger faction. Significantly, early indications also show that around 18,000 Jews voted for the JL this week – a tiny minority worth less than half a Knesset seat, but an order of magnitude larger than in any past election – and a signal that future growth is entirely possible. More important in immediate electoral terms is the huge reserve of Palestinians who do not vote out of apathy rather than ideology, and who could easily earn an invigorated Joint List another four or five seats.

In the long run, any hope for a peaceful and democratic decolonization of Palestine will require convincing a majority of the Israeli polity of the necessity of peace. In recent years, this possibility has grown dimmer and dimmer, but the collapse of the Zionist left and the rise of the Joint List could represent a new opportunity for realignment. A left grouped around the Palestinian minority, centering its demands as a part of the Palestinian people, as a decidely working-class demographic, and as an assertive part of the Israeli polity, could be the beginning of something transformative. The Joint List is that beginning, and as such it deserves both attention and solidarity.